🍦 Top Ice Cream Stops Near Niagara Falls (& Beyond)
At Go Niagara Tours, we get asked this question all the time—and we don’t blame you. After a long day exploring the Falls, walking Goat Island, or riding the Maid of the Mist, you’ve earned a treat. But not just any cone will do. We’re talking about the creamiest custards, the wildest soft-serve twists, and the most unforgettable flavors in the region.
Whether you’re in the heart of Niagara Falls, cruising up to charming Lewiston, or venturing out toward Buffalo, there’s no shortage of sweet spots. From iconic roadside stands to hidden artisan gems, this guide dishes out our favorite places to grab a cone, a cup, or even a chocolate-dipped waffle creation you’ll dream about for years.
Let’s scoop!
🌊 1. Hibbard’s Original Frozen Custard – Lewiston
Just a few miles north of Niagara Falls, tucked in the charming village of Lewiston, Hibbard’s deserves top billing. This family-run stand has been churning ultra-creamy frozen custard since the 1930s. Custard lovers rave:
“After tasting this custard, I wouldn’t want to have custard anywhere else.”
“Black Raspberry Custard is a must.”
It consistently ranks as the best ice cream spot in town—and even across Western New York . Worth the short detour and often crowded—but worth every lick.
Location: 105 Portage Road, Lewiston
Why it stands out: Rich, less-aerated custard in nostalgic village atmosphere.
2. De Dee’s Dairy – Niagara Falls, NY
A local staple just south of the Falls, known for generous scoop sizes and a rotating flavor lineup. It’s an ideal post-tour treat—but skip it if you’re looking for artisan; this is classic, simple, satisfying ice cream .
3. Twist O’ The Mist – Downtown Niagara Falls
An iconic cone-shaped shop near Rainbow Blvd serving Perry’s soft-serve. Perfect for families—and fun for photos. It’s touristy, yes, but also a Falls classic .
4. Hoover’s Restaurant & Dairy Store – Sanborn
About 15 miles east, this century-old dairy farm offers ice cream alongside farm-fresh meals. In a scenic setting, their ice cream pairs beautifully with countryside vibes .
5. Platter’s Chocolate Factory – North Tonawanda
A chocolate-lover’s dream just north of Buffalo. Famous for its orange-spiked custard and signature hot fudge, it’s a creative twist on tradition .
6. Prohaska’s Oh Sugar! – Niagara Falls, USA side
A newer boutique in town, offering 40+ flavors of both soft and hard ice cream, plus cupcakes. Seasonal, but vibrant and sweet .
8. Rosie’s Handcrafted Ice Cream – East Aurora & Buffalo
For those willing to head a bit farther, Rosie’s is absolutely worth the drive. With locations in East Aurora and Buffalo’s Five Points, Rosie’s crafts super-premium small-batch ice cream, complete with homemade waffle cones, vegan options, and unique creations like “Hot Tacolates” and spicy sorbets . It’s an artisanal treat that boosts any ice cream tour.
✅ Final Scoop
Here’s your go-to guide for satisfying every sweet tooth:
Start in Lewiston with Hibbard’s Frozen Custard—a creamy, old-school favorite that’s stood the test of time.
Stay in Niagara Falls for quick, family-friendly stops like Twist O’ The Mist (iconic and fun) or De Dee’s Dairy(big scoops, local legend).
Go the extra mile to Rosie’s or Lake Effect for small-batch, artisanal creations that are 100% worth the trip.
For chocolate lovers, Platter’s Chocolate Factory serves up rich, indulgent custard with a unique twist.
Whether your guests want classic cones or bold, handcrafted flavors, this list has something for everyone. So go ahead—treat them to a taste of the region.
Let the tours roll—and the ice cream melt! 🍦
Did we miss your favorite scoop spot? Let us know!
We’re always on the lookout for hidden gems to share with our guests on Go Niagara Tours.